Thursday, October 8, 2026

The Political Use of "We"

In his overdue and too little appreciated challenge to mainstream environmentalism Austerity Ecology Leigh Phillips remarked the penchant of a certain kind of political commentator for the use of the "blasted undifferentiating first-person plural pronoun" "we," as in statements such as "In the face of the environmental crisis we chose more stuff over sustainability."

In doing so Phillips raised a point with a salience extending far beyond ecological concern to contemporary political discourse broadly that becomes evident when "we" unpack the "blasted, undifferentiating first-person plural pronoun," with particular attention to its "undifferentiating" character. To speak of such a thing as the course of the nation's economy--of a course of "more stuff" over "sustainability"--as something "we" determined implies that that course was meaningfully a product of collective decision-making by society at large. But was it? The plain and simple reality is that in contemporary life power is not broadly, let alone equally, distributed through society but concentrated in a comparatively small number of institutions, which tend to be hierarchical and authoritarian in nature, and controlled by a very few, all as the rest of the populace has very little say, if any, in what goes on. Indeed, a recent systematic, comprehensive examination of political outcomes found that where it was discernible public preferences seemed to have no effect on policy outcomes whatsoever.

The use of the word "we" slights that reality of concentrated power--and indeed obfuscates it behind the myth of "consensus" so much promoted by career gas-lighters of the American public like Robert Dahl and his centrist fellow-travelers. Meanwhile as it conceals the concentration of power it removes responsibility from those who are truly powerful and places it on the heads of "everyone" in that way "we" see so much of among those who blame the hapless consumer for the ecological crisis, who tell working-class people to mind their carbon footprint, as they completely ignore what Wall Street, Big Oil and the rest do. It may well be that some of those who do this are simply stupid, unthinkingly repeating what they have heard--the more in as it is being said so much. But the broader tendency is not innocent in the slightest. (For instance, consider just who originated that term "carbon footprint.") The result is that you would indeed do well to be wary of those who would too casually throw around the word "we" when discussing the causes of the big problems in the world, and what "we" will have to do to resolve them.

No comments:

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon